What it is

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High is a washable, buildable mascara in Blackest Black, worn for length and some volume without a waterproof formula that is harder to take off. It is a widely available everyday makeup item, not a lash serum, and not a waterproof sport mascara. As with any mascara, it should be replaced on a regular schedule and used as the label directs if your eyes are sensitive.

Who it is for

This mascara suits people who want a regular black mascara for daily wear and prefer a washable formula that comes off with standard makeup remover. It is less ideal if you need a waterproof formula for swimming, heavy sweating, or very long wear, or if you only want clear brow gel. If your eyes are sensitive, read the label and consider patching a new mascara carefully.

Features to check before you buy

Pros

  • A washable formula is usually easier to remove at night than waterproof mascara.
  • Blackest Black is a standard everyday shade.
  • A buildable mascara lets you keep the look light or add a little more, depending on the day.
  • It is a widely sold item, which makes a repurchase straightforward.

Tradeoffs

  • Washable mascara may smear more easily than waterproof formulas in humidity, rain, or a long, teary day.
  • Like all mascara, it needs to be replaced regularly and should not be shared.
  • Sensitive eyes can react to many mascaras; the label matters more than a famous name.
  • It will not, on its own, replace a lash curler, primer, or serum if those are part of your routine.

How it compares

There is no second mascara on this site, so the comparison is about the rest of a makeup-removal routine. If you wear this mascara, you will also want a way to take it off, such as the Neutrogena makeup remover wipes, or a rinse-off cleanser followed by the Clean Skin Club towels. Those are companions, not alternatives. If you need waterproof mascara, look for that wording on Amazon rather than assuming a washable tube will stay put in water.

Buying tip

Replace mascara on a regular schedule, and do not pump the wand, which can dry out the tube. If you often swim or sweat through your makeup, look at a waterproof formula instead of this washable one.